Canadian banks can create a new asset class called carbon insets by integrating emission-reduction agreements into green bonds, requiring regulatory changes and innovation. Carbon insets focus on internal emission reductions within supply chains, enhancing financial institutions' roles in climate finance. Current policies support sustainable finance but lack recognition for carbon insets, creating gaps in monetization. Recommendations include amending regulations, clarifying tax treatment, and enhancing data infrastructure to facilitate the development of this market, positioning Canadian banks as leaders in climate finance.
Monetizing Carbon Insets in Canada’s Financial System
Canadian banks can unlock a new, high-integrity asset class—carbon insets—by embedding value-chain emission-reduction agreements inside green bonds and other sustainable-finance instruments. Achieving this requires targeted changes to federal offset regulations, taxonomy guidance, disclosure rules, and prudential standards, alongside proactive product innovation by the banking sector[1][2][3].
1 Reframing the Opportunity: From Offsets to Insets
1.1 What Are Carbon Insets?
Carbon insets finance verifiable emission reductions within a company’s supply or distribution network, aligning decarbonization capital with core operations rather than purchasing credits from external projects[1][4]. Insets deliver Scope 3 abatement, enhance supply security, and avoid reputational concerns associated with low-quality offsets[5][6].
Comparison of carbon offsetting and carbon insetting showing external purchase versus internal implementation of emission reductions.
1.2 Why Financial Institutions Matter
Banks, insurers, and pension funds sit at the nexus of climate capital flows. Pre-market purchasing agreements, transition loans, and green bonds backed by inset claims can channel low-cost capital toward upstream producers (e.g., farmers adopting regenerative practices) while generating a bookable asset that improves financed-emissions metrics under PCAF[7] and supports net-zero commitments under SBTi criteria[8].
2 Current Canadian Policy Architecture Supporting Insets
Key policy milestones shaping Canada’s sustainable-finance ecosystem relevant to carbon insetting.
2.1 Carbon Pricing and Federal Offset Credit System
- Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act (2018) created the legal foundation for pricing and trading emissions[2].
- SOR/2022-111 Canadian Greenhouse Gas Offset Credit System Regulations established nationwide protocols but currently recognize only offset projects—no explicit pathway for value-chain inset credits[9][10].
- Federal protocols for landfill gas, refrigeration, forest management, and manure methane illustrate how activity-specific methodologies are codified[11][12].
2.2 Sustainable-Finance Taxonomy and Green Bonds
- Sustainable Finance Action Council (SFAC) “Taxonomy Roadmap Report” (2022) proposes dual Green and Transition labels tied to science-based thresholds[3][13].
- Federal Green Bond Framework (2022; updated 2023) channels issuance proceeds to eligible climate expenditures and now includes nuclear energy[14][15].
- Three sovereign green bonds (2022-2025) have mobilized $11 billion, demonstrating investor appetite for rigorously reported use-of-proceeds instruments[16][17].
2.3 Disclosure and Prudential Oversight
- OSFI Guideline B-15 (2023, updated 2025) mandates climate-risk governance and scenario analysis for all federally regulated financial institutions (FRFIs), delaying Scope 3 disclosure to 2028 but expecting progress on financed-emissions measurement[18][19].
- CSA National Instrument 51-107 will introduce mandatory TCFD-aligned reporting for issuers once harmonized with Canadian Sustainability Standards Board (CSSB) requirements[20][21].
2.4 Voluntary Standards and Verification Infrastructure
- Verra VCS, Gold Standard, Climate Action Reserve and other registries provide accreditation pathways that could be adapted for inset methodologies[22][23].
- SOCIALCARBON and Gold Standard scope-3 guidance outline project-boundary, double-counting, and permanence rules tailored to insetting[24].
3 Gaps Impeding Monetization of Carbon Insets
3.1 Regulatory Recognition
The federal offset framework lacks a category for “value-chain emissions reduction credits” that remain inside the originating supply chain, preventing banks from booking insets as eligible collateral or green-bond underlying assets[2][10].
3.2 Accounting and Tax Treatment
The Canada Carbon Rebate for Small Business is currently taxable—illustrating uncertainty around government climate-related payments[25][26]. Comparable ambiguity exists for inset-related revenue streams, deterring corporate participation.
3.3 Certification and Data Quality
Inset projects require measurable, additional Scope 3 reductions consistent with GHG Protocol and PCAF rules yet must avoid double-claiming with supplier inventories[7][27]. Lack of a nationally endorsed inset verification protocol hinders investor confidence.
3.4 Disclosure Alignment
Delayed Scope 3 disclosure under OSFI B-15 and CSSB means banks may not immediately receive regulatory credit for inset-linked de-risking of their loan books[18][28].
4 Policy and Regulatory Recommendations
4.1 Amend the Offset Regulations
- Add a “Value-Chain Insetting” project category to SOR/2022-111 with quantification methods for regenerative agriculture, low-methane livestock feed, bio-industrial circularity, and clean fuel switching inside supply contracts[29][12].
- Permit issuance of Inset Credits (ICs) restricted to use by the purchasing entity and its financiers, thereby preserving environmental integrity while avoiding secondary-market distortions.
4.2 Integrate Insets into the Taxonomy
- Define inset-eligible activities under the Transition label where Scope 3 decarbonization pathways are science-aligned but technologically or geographically constrained[3][30].
- Provide guidance for structuring green-bond use-of-proceeds toward inset projects, mirroring EU taxonomy “Do No Significant Harm” tests.
4.3 Clarify Accounting and Tax Rules
- Issue CRA interpretation bulletins aligning inset-credit income recognition with International Financial Reporting Standard IFRS S2 climate disclosures, ensuring symmetrical treatment across industries.
- Allow accelerated depreciation or investment tax credits for capital assets purchased to fulfill inset agreements, similar to clean-technology ITCs.
4.4 Enhance Data Infrastructure
- Fund an open Canadian Inset Registry interoperable with Verra, Gold Standard, and federal CATS to track issuance, retirement, and ownership, preventing double-counting[10][22].
- Mandate PCAF-aligned financed-emissions reporting by 2027 to synchronize with OSFI and CSSB timelines, giving banks a “regulatory runway” to pilot inset products[19][7].
5 Strategic Actions for Canadian Banks
5.1 Product Development
- Structure Pre-paid Forward Insets—similar to commodity prepayment facilities—where the bank advances funds to suppliers in exchange for future IC delivery, de-risked via performance insurance[31][32].
- Embed Inset Performance Triggers in sustainability-linked loans and bonds, with coupon step-downs when suppliers achieve verified emission-intensity milestones[33][34].
5.2 Risk Management and Verification
- Adopt robust due-diligence frameworks using third-party verifiers and satellite/IoT monitoring to confirm emission reductions, mitigating greenwashing risk[24][35].
- Include inset exposure in climate-risk scenario analysis and capital planning to meet OSFI B-15 expectations[18][36].
5.3 Partnerships and Ecosystem Building
- Collaborate with ag-tech, bio-industrial parks, and Indigenous-led stewardship projects (e.g., Métis Settlement initiatives) to generate high-integrity inset supply aligned with reconciliation and Just Transition goals[37].
- Pilot Greener Future Financingstyle programs that tie loan discounts to inset generation, as demonstrated by BMO’s $30 million agriculture facility[38][39].
5.4 Transparency and Market Signalling
- Publish inset methodologies, audit results, and impact dashboards within annual TCFD/CSSB reports, boosting investor confidence and secondary-market liquidity for inset-backed securities[20][40].
6 Conclusion
Canada’s policy scaffolding for sustainable finance—carbon pricing, green bonds, taxonomy, and climate disclosure—is largely in place, but explicit recognition of carbon insets is the missing link that will convert supply-chain decarbonization into investable, liquid assets[3][2][14]. By updating offset regulations, finalizing taxonomy criteria, and clarifying tax/accounting treatment, policymakers can unlock billions in pre-market commitments and green-bond proceeds for projects that cut emissions at the source.
For their part, Canadian banks should seize first-mover advantage: build verification-ready inset pipelines, design forward-financing structures, and integrate inset metrics into risk and disclosure frameworks. Doing so will not only reduce financed emissions but also position the sector as a global leader in value-chain climate finance—turning carbon liabilities into bankable assets that drive Canada’s transition to net-zero prosperity[16][33][18].
Sources
- https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/03/carbon-insetting-vs-offsetting-an-explainer/
- https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-2022-111/section-1.html
- https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/fin/publications/sfac-camfd/2022/09/2022-09-eng.pdf
- https://www.engieimpact.com/insights/carbon-insetting&rut=4219e103af73dc1a32d226f2826024c9c719cb3bf437faa39b735742e6be7b95
- https://www.sylvera.com/blog/insetting
- https://www.resonanceglobal.com/blog/carbon-insetting-vs-offsetting-a-primer-for-sustainability-leaders
- https://www.canadianlenders.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/The-Guide-to-the-Partnership-for-Carbon-Accounting-Financials-PCAF.pdf
- https://ungc-communications-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/docs/publications/SBTi-Corporate-Manual.pdf
- https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/climate-change/pricing-pollution-how-it-will-work/output-based-pricing-system/federal-greenhouse-gas-offset-system.html
- https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/climate-change/pricing-pollution-how-it-will-work/output-based-pricing-system/federal-greenhouse-gas-offset-system/regulations/overview.html
- https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/climate-change/pricing-pollution-how-it-will-work/output-based-pricing-system/federal-greenhouse-gas-offset-system/compendium-protocols.html
- https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/climate-change/pricing-pollution-how-it-will-work/output-based-pricing-system/federal-greenhouse-gas-offset-system/protocols.html
- https://climateinstitute.ca/news/canadas-new-climate-investment-taxonomy-framework-critical-to-securing-competitiveness-achieving-targets-experts-say/
- https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/fin/publications/green-bond/Green Bond Framework 2023.pdf
- https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/financial-sector-policy/securities/debt-program/canadas-green-bond-program.html
- https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2025/02/canada-to-issue-third-green-bond.html
- https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2024/10/canada-to-re-open-10-year-green-bond.html
- https://www.mccarthy.ca/en/insights/publications/osfi-releases-updated-guideline-climate-risk-management
- https://www.dentons.com/en/insights/alerts/2025/march/11/aligning-osfis-guideline-b15-on-climate-risk-management
- https://www.dentons.com/en/insights/articles/2021/november/12/canadian-securities-administrators
- https://www.iasplus.com/en-ca/projects/esg-projects-deloitte-cfr/exposure-drafts/csa-proposed-national-instrument-ni-51-107-disclosure-of-climate-related-matters-ed
- https://certifiedcarbon.com/who-verifies-carbon-credits
- https://www.ncmc.sua.ac.tz/carbon-credit-certifiers/
- https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6161c89d030b89374bec0b70/t/6756f559615b7566262c87aa/1733752156140/SOCIALCARBON-Insetting_Requirements_vPublic_Consultation.pdf
- https://www.cpacanada.ca/news/Accounting/Tax/carbon-rebate
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTbmtQ51GtA
- http://pdf.wri.org/ghg_protocol.pdf
- https://www.iasplus.com/en-ca/standards/sustainability-1/other-sustainability-reporting-frameworks/osfi-guideline-b-15-climate-risk-management
- https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2024/eccc/en4/En4-472-2024-eng.pdf
- https://www.riacanada.ca/magazine/canadas-green-and-transition-finance-taxonomy-what-does-it-mean-for-investors/
- https://docs.solid.world/background-information/what-is-prepaid-forward-financing
- https://lune.co/blog/different-ways-to-buy-carbon-explained-from-spot-purchases-to-multi-year-agreements
- https://institute.smartprosperity.ca/Sustainability-Linked-Bonds
- https://www.mccarthy.ca/en/insights/publications/green-shift-sustainability-finance-canadian-loan-market
- https://ecocart.io/how-carbon-credits-are-verified/
- https://www.newswire.ca/news-releases/osfi-issues-new-guideline-on-climate-risk-management-886734477.html
- https://cgspace.cgiar.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/e8b33c32-8d44-4a85-bd1c-4f9697c24f24/content
- https://about.bmo.com/a-greener-future-bmos-new-30-million-financing-program-for-agriculture-businesses-in-canada/
- https://newsroom.bmo.com/2023-04-19-BMO-Launches-Greener-Future-Financing-Program-for-Agriculture-Businesses
- https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/financial-sector-policy/securities/debt-program/green-bond-allocation-impact-report-2023-24.html